Newsflash: 4 Bed, 3.5 Bath Vs. 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath with Loft

Curious which house would hold more value in the long term, this is in an urban HCOL area. A house with 4 bed and 3.5 bath on a standard lot with a 20′ X 36′ backyard or a 3 bed, 2.5 bath with open to below loft on a pie lot with 20′ X 90′ backyard? Both houses are in the same neighbourhood. Both houses share similar usuable square footage at around 2650 sq ft. Would one be better for resale and why? (What are the considerations)